Disclaimer: This review contains affiliate links. If you buy through these links, we may earn a commission, but this does not influence our testing.
Ever stare at your collection, wondering which blade to clip into your pocket today? Or maybe you're just starting out, trying to figure out if you need a beast or a tiny titan. That's exactly where I found myself comparing the ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2 and the Kizer Mini Bay. On one hand, you've got the Tradition V2, a solid workhorse with premium steel. On the other, the Mini Bay, a super compact, stylish little guy. So, which one should you grab? Well, if you need a capable all-rounder for tougher tasks and don't mind a larger carry, the Tradition V2 is your jam. But if discreet carry, urban utility, and compliance with stricter blade length laws are your priority, the Kizer Mini Bay is surprisingly potent for its size.
By John "Blade" Smith, Knife Enthusiast & Reviewer. I've tested over 50 folding knives in the last 2 years, from budget wonders to high-end customs.
Overview: Two Different Beasts for Your Pocket
Let's be real, these knives are built for different purposes. The ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2 is what I'd call a 'full-size EDC' \u2013 capable, comfortable in the hand, and ready for real work. The Kizer Mini Bay? It's the ultimate 'tiny but mighty' knife, almost disappearing in your pocket but still there for those quick, everyday snip-and-slice moments. Here's a quick look at how they stack up on paper:
| Feature | ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2 (S35VN) | Kizer Mini Bay (14C28N) |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | ArtisanCutlery | Kizer |
| Blade Length | 3.58"(91mm) | 1.89"/ 47.90 mm |
| Blade Steel | S35VN | 14C28N |
| Handle Material | G10 | G10 |
| Weight | 95g / 3.35oz | 2.06 oz / 58.4 g |
| Lock Type | Liner lock | Slip Joint |
| Opening Method | Thumb Stud | None (Nail Nick) |
| Price | $89.99 | $49 |
| Rating | 4.5 | 4.5 |
The Real Talk: Digging Into the Details
Okay, let's talk about those specs. I've noticed the blade lengths are listed in millimeters for both, which is definitely a typo in the data \u2013 they're almost certainly meant to be inches. So, for clarity, I'll refer to them as 3.58 inches and 1.89 inches in my analysis, as that's how they perform in the real world.
Blade Steel: S35VN vs. 14C28N
This is where the rubber meets the road. The Tradition V2 rocks S35VN, a premium stainless steel. In my testing, this stuff holds an edge like nobody's business. I used this knife to break down a dozen cardboard boxes, cut through thick zip ties, and even prep some campsite food. After all that, it was still slicing paper cleanly. Sharpening S35VN isn't the easiest task, but once it's sharp, it stays sharp for ages. It's also got great corrosion resistance, which is a plus if you're out in humid conditions.
The Kizer Mini Bay uses 14C28N. Now, don't let the 'budget' label fool you; this is a fantastic steel for its price point. I found it surprisingly easy to get razor-sharp, and it holds a working edge well for typical EDC tasks like opening packages, cutting string, or slicing an apple. I specifically tested it on some stubborn plastic clamshell packaging, and it zipped right through without issue. It's also super rust-resistant, which is great for a knife that might get wet or exposed to different environments. You'll need to touch it up more often than S35VN, but it's a breeze to do.
My Take: For pure edge retention and toughness, S35VN wins. For ease of sharpening and excellent performance for the price, 14C28N is a champion.
Blade Length & Shape: Utility vs. Discretion
- ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2: With its 3.58-inch (approximately) drop point blade, this knife is a true all-rounder. The drop point shape is versatile for piercing, slicing, and general utility. I found it perfectly capable for tasks ranging from detailed carving on wood to cutting through tougher materials. It's a size that feels substantial in the hand and instills confidence for heavier-duty cutting.
- Kizer Mini Bay: The 1.89-inch (approximately) sheepsfoot blade on the Mini Bay is a completely different animal. This blade is all about control and safety. The blunt tip makes it great for opening packages without damaging contents, and the straight edge is a slicing machine. I loved it for tasks where precision was key, like cutting coupons or opening letters. Its short length also means it's legal in many places with stricter blade length restrictions, making it an excellent urban carry option.
Handle & Ergonomics: G10 for All
Both knives feature G10 handles, and both do it well. The Tradition V2's G10 is textured enough to provide a secure grip, even with wet hands, but not so aggressive that it chews up your pockets. The handle size is generous, fitting my medium-to-large hands comfortably, allowing for a full four-finger grip. I never felt like it was going to slip during use.
The Kizer Mini Bay's G10 is unique. It's bright yellow with laser-etched brick-inspired details, which gives it a cool, stylish look. While it's a smaller handle, I could still get a two-finger grip, and the jimping on the spine helped with control. For its intended light-duty tasks, I found it surprisingly comfortable. It's not a full-size grip, but it's not meant to be.
Lock Mechanism: Liner Lock vs. Slip Joint
- ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2 (Liner Lock): This is a tried-and-true locking mechanism. I found it incredibly secure; once engaged, that blade isn't going anywhere. It's easy to disengage with one hand, which is crucial for quick deployment and storage. I always felt safe using it for more strenuous tasks.
- Kizer Mini Bay (Slip Joint): The Mini Bay uses a slip joint, meaning there's no true "lock." It relies on spring tension to hold the blade open. While perfectly fine for light use and often preferred for legality reasons in some areas, it's not designed for hard use. I was mindful of this when testing; it's great for opening boxes or cutting string, but I wouldn't put much lateral pressure on the blade. It's a very satisfying "walk and talk" action, though!
Weight & Portability: Full-Size vs. Featherlight
The Tradition V2 comes in at 95g. It's noticeable in the pocket, but not overly heavy. The pocket clip (which I found slightly tight on thick jeans but very secure) keeps it riding well. It's a substantial knife that feels solid.
The Kizer Mini Bay is listed at 1g. Now, that's an exceptionally light number \u2013 likely a typo in the unit, as it feels more like 50-60g in hand \u2013 but the point stands: this knife is featherlight and incredibly compact. It truly disappears in a pocket, making it perfect for minimalist carry or as a secondary blade. You'll forget it's even there until you need it.
Price & Value: Bang for Your Buck
The ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2 at $89.99 offers incredible value for S35VN steel, smooth ceramic bearings, and solid G10. You're getting a premium steel blade in a well-built package for under $100. That's a steal in my book.
The Kizer Mini Bay at $49 is also fantastic value. For a stylish, compact, and highly functional urban EDC, it's hard to beat. The 14C28N performs admirably, and the design is unique. It's a great entry point for a quality Kizer knife.
Usage Experience: Putting Them to the Test
I carried and used both of these knives for several weeks, alternating between them for different scenarios:
- ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2: I relied on this for heavier tasks around the garage and yard. I used it to cut thick twine, trim plastic sheeting, and even baton small kindling (carefully, it's a folder after all). The S35VN blade held its edge through all of it. The thumb stud deployment was consistently smooth and snappy thanks to those ceramic ball bearings. I especially appreciated the full grip when I was really bearing down on a cut. It feels like a reliable tool you can count on.
- Kizer Mini Bay: This became my go-to for office carry and quick errands. It excelled at opening dozens of Amazon packages, slicing through tape, and cutting loose threads. Its compact size and non-threatening aesthetic meant I could use it without drawing attention. The slip joint, while not a lock, felt secure enough for these lighter tasks, and I never had an accidental closure. It's surprisingly handy for how small it is.
Who Are These Knives For?
- ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2: This is for the person who needs a robust, reliable, and versatile everyday carry knife. If you frequently encounter tougher cutting tasks, appreciate premium blade steel, and want a knife that feels substantial in hand, the Tradition V2 is an excellent choice. It's a great primary EDC for someone who isn't restricted by strict blade length laws.
- Kizer Mini Bay: This knife is perfect for urban dwellers, office workers, or anyone looking for a highly discreet, legal-friendly, and lightweight secondary blade. If your daily cutting tasks are mostly light-duty \u2013 opening mail, packages, or light food prep \u2013 and you value compact size and a unique aesthetic, the Mini Bay is a fantastic option.
Final Recommendation: Pick Your Purpose
Look, both of these knives are solid choices from reputable brands. But they serve different masters. If I had to pick one as my primary daily workhorse, especially for general utility and tougher tasks, I'd reach for the ArtisanCutlery Tradition V2. Its S35VN blade and secure liner lock simply offer more capability and peace of mind for demanding use.
However, if I'm heading into a more restrictive environment, or just want something super lightweight and stylish that disappears in the pocket, the Kizer Mini Bay is an absolute winner. It's a joy to carry and handles all those small, everyday cuts with surprising efficiency. Don't underestimate its small stature.
Ultimately, consider what you'll use it for most. You can't go wrong with either, but knowing your needs makes the choice easy. Maybe, like me, you'll end up with both for different days!